Westerly

Westerly is a Rhode Island beach short-term rental destination anchored by Watch Hill and Misquamicut Beach, suited to physician investors seeking coastal vacation-rental income. Properties average about $265 per night at 60% occupancy — roughly $159 RevPAR and around $4,770 in monthly revenue — against a purchase price near $495,000, a 22.9× GRM and 3.0% cap rate. Summer beach demand drives strong seasonal cash flow. Moderate short-term-rental regulations apply, so verify local short-term-rental rules before closing. For doctors wanting a proven New England coastal STR, Westerly is a well-positioned seasonal play.

Market Analysis

Why physicians are looking at Westerly

Westerly owns two of New England's proven beach names: Watch Hill and Misquamicut. That pairing covers both ends of the coastal market — prestige shoreline on one side, high-energy beach crowds on the other — and gives the town a summer demand engine that has run reliably for generations. For physician investors, Westerly is the entry point into Rhode Island's coastal STR tier at its most accessible price.

The numbers, interpreted

Underwrite it as a hospitality business. Listings average about $265/night at 60% occupancy — roughly $159 RevPAR and around $4,770/mo in gross revenue — against a purchase price near $495,000 (22.9× GRM, ~3.0% cap on long-term math, which says the STR strategy is what earns the price). The season is the shape to respect: revenue concentrates in the beach window, so annual numbers depend on how well the shoulder months are marketed. Compare Narragansett, where ~$295 ADR drives ~$5,487/mo at a $695,000 basis, or Newport at ~$4,560/mo on $685,000 — Westerly produces comparable revenue at $200,000 less buy-in, which is precisely its argument.

Costs and rules to underwrite

Property taxes at 1.63% run roughly $8,070 per year on a $495,000 property — a serious fixed line against seasonal revenue. Westerly operates under moderate short-term-rental regulations, so verify the current local rules — registration, zoning, limits — before closing, not after. And because beach guests shop listings side by side, themed properties and standout amenities that photograph memorably routinely out-book commodity cottages at the same rate.

Building your local team in Westerly

Before wiring a deposit, get a second opinion the way you'd insist on one before major surgery: an independent revenue projection from a professional STR manager and a real inspection, both checked against the seller's pro-forma. The team carries the outcome from there — it will make or break the investment. You'll want STR management that can fill June and September (July fills itself), an investor-focused realtor who knows which streets near Watch Hill and Misquamicut actually book, furnishing capital budgeted up front, and DSCR financing sized on conservative annualized numbers. Dr Home Investor shortcuts the roster-building by introducing vetted local team members — including a Realtor match with boots on the ground on the Rhode Island coast — rather than leaving a busy physician to a blind Google search.

Bottom line

Westerly is the value entry to Rhode Island's beach STR tier: ~$265/night, 60% occupancy, about $4,770/mo gross on a $495,000 basis, powered by Watch Hill and Misquamicut demand. Underwrite the ~$8,070 tax bill and the seasonal revenue curve honestly, verify local STR rules first, and presentation-invest to win bookings. For physicians wanting proven New England beach exposure without Newport pricing, it's the sensible open. Explore other Rhode Island markets for the full coastal lineup. Short-term rentals ask more of their owners — our guide to passive real estate investing for doctors shows how to keep one hands-off on clinic hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Westerly a good short-term rental market for physician investors?

Yes — it's the accessible entry to Rhode Island's coastal STR tier: about $265/night at 60% occupancy, roughly $4,770/mo gross, on a ~$495,000 purchase anchored by Watch Hill and Misquamicut Beach.

How much does a short-term rental cost in Westerly?

Around $495,000, producing roughly $159 RevPAR and ~$4,770/mo in gross seasonal revenue at a $265 average nightly rate.

What do Westerly STRs earn compared with Newport or Narragansett?

Comparable revenue at a lower basis: ~$4,770/mo on $495,000, versus Newport's ~$4,560/mo on $685,000 and Narragansett's ~$5,487/mo on $695,000.

Are short-term rentals legal in Westerly?

Moderate STR regulations apply. Verify the town's current registration, zoning, and rental rules for your specific property before closing — coastal communities revise these regularly.

What's the biggest underwriting risk in Westerly?

Seasonality against fixed costs. Revenue concentrates in the beach window while ~$8,070/yr in property tax (1.63%) runs year-round — model shoulder months conservatively.

Investment Snapshot

Median Home Value

$495,000.00

Single family

Monthly rent

$1,800.00

Market Average

Gross rent mult.

22.9x

Lower = Better

Est. cap rate

~3.0%

Gross estimate

Property tax rate

1.63%

State average

Rental Strategy Performance

Monthly rent

$1,800.00

Est Market Average

Annual gross rent
$21,600
Pre-expense

Gross rent mult.

22.9x

Lower = Better

Est. cap rate

~3.0%

Before financing

Cash Flow Calculator

Purchase Price$495,000
Down Payment25%
Interest Rate3.25%
Monthly Rent$1,800
Monthly Cash Flow-$1,018/mo
Cash-on-Cash Return-8.8%
Total Cash Needed$138,600

Assumes 5% vacancy, 8% property management, 5% capex reserve, and state-average insurance. For illustration only.

All 12

Rhode Island

Markets

All figures are estimates based on publicly available market data and are for general research purposes only. Cap rates, rent estimates, and STR performance are market averages and do not guarantee individual property performance. Consult a licensed real estate professional, CPA, or attorney before making investment decisions. Dr Home Investor does not guarantee the accuracy of third-party market data.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.