Long Beach Island

Long Beach Island is a Jersey Shore short-term rental hub suited to physician investors seeking peak summer income. Properties average about $365 per night at 68% occupancy — roughly $248 RevPAR and around $7,446 in monthly revenue — against a purchase price near $735,000, with New Jersey's 2.23% property tax as a heavy line item. As a Shore STR hub, it posts the highest summer occupancy in the state, concentrating cash flow in the warm months. Moderate short-term-rental regulations apply and long-term landlord rules are strict, so verify local short-term-rental rules before closing. For doctors, it offers peak-season STR upside that must be underwritten against high taxes.

Market Analysis

Why physicians are looking at Long Beach Island

Long Beach Island is the Shore's summer machine: the highest summer occupancy in New Jersey, concentrated on an 18-mile barrier island where generations of families book the same weeks annually. The demand isn't discovered — it's inherited. For physician investors, LBI offers the purest version of the peak-season strategy: extraordinary summer economics, quiet winters, and an asset class families hold for decades.

The numbers, interpreted

Roughly $365/night at 68% occupancy produces about $248 RevPAR and around $7,446/month against a $735,000 basis — a 27.2× GRM and 2.3% cap. Run the differential before falling for the summer pro-forma: the deal-killers to rule out are winter carry (taxes and insurance continue when bookings stop), coastal insurance costs on a barrier island, and the season's compression — most of the year's revenue arrives in roughly a quarter of it. Those checks, not the July rate card, decide whether the deal works. Within the Shore set, Cape May runs higher ADR ($425/night) with a longer season at $685,000, and Asbury Park offers the revival-town alternative at $595,000. LBI wins on peak-week depth; the others win on season length.

Costs and rules to underwrite

New Jersey's 2.23% property tax is roughly $16,390/yr at this basis — the heaviest tax bill in this state set. Moderate short-term-rental regulations apply and long-term landlord rules are strict, so verify local short-term-rental rules in the specific LBI municipality before closing (the island spans several, and rules differ). Quote wind and flood insurance before offering; barrier-island coverage is a defining line item. Reserves should carry the property through the off-season at full cost with zero revenue — that's the honest stress test for any barrier-island hold.

Building your local team in Long Beach Island

Peak-season markets are won operationally, and the team will make or break the summer. You want a vacation-rental manager with an established LBI book and Saturday-turnover machinery, an investor-focused realtor who knows which towns and blocks on the island carry which rates, and furnishing built for the family-reunion guest — memorable, well-equipped houses out-earn commodity units when families compare listings for their one big week. Dr Home Investor introduces you to vetted local team members — including a Realtor match with real island knowledge — replacing the blind Google search with operators who already run this coastline. Ask candidate managers how many LBI turnovers they run on a summer Saturday; capacity during peak weeks is the whole job.

Bottom line

LBI concentrates New Jersey's strongest summer occupancy into around $7,446/month at peak-season rates, carried on a $735,000 basis with roughly $16,390/yr in taxes. Underwrite the winter and the insurance, then let the summer do its work. Explore other New Jersey markets for longer-season and yield alternatives. Weighing vacation-rental income against your timeline to financial independence? See physician FIRE through real estate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Long Beach Island a good short-term rental market for physicians?

Yes, for peak-season strategy. LBI posts the highest summer occupancy in New Jersey, averaging about $365/night at 68% occupancy — roughly $7,446/month — on a $735,000 basis.

How much does an LBI STR property cost?

Around $735,000, producing roughly $248 RevPAR — the highest basis in this New Jersey group, priced for the island's inherited family demand.

How seasonal is LBI revenue?

Highly. Most annual revenue arrives in the summer quarter, while roughly $16,390/yr in property taxes and barrier-island insurance run year-round — model winter carry explicitly.

Are short-term rentals allowed on Long Beach Island?

Moderate regulations apply, and LBI spans several municipalities with differing rules — verify the specific town's licensing and rental requirements before closing.

What insurance should I underwrite for a barrier-island property?

Wind and flood coverage are defining line items on LBI — quote both before making an offer, because they materially change net returns against the ~$7,446/month gross.

Investment Snapshot

Median Home Value

$735,000.00

Single family

Monthly rent

$2,250.00

Market Average

Gross rent mult.

27.2x

Lower = Better

Est. cap rate

~2.3%

Gross estimate

Property tax rate

2.23%

State average

Rental Strategy Performance

Monthly rent

$2,250.00

Est Market Average

Annual gross rent
$27,000
Pre-expense

Gross rent mult.

27.2x

Lower = Better

Est. cap rate

~2.3%

Before financing

Cash Flow Calculator

Purchase Price$735,000
Down Payment25%
Interest Rate3.25%
Monthly Rent$2,250
Monthly Cash Flow-$2,226/mo
Cash-on-Cash Return-13.0%
Total Cash Needed$205,800

Assumes 5% vacancy, 8% property management, 5% capex reserve, and state-average insurance. For illustration only.

All 12

New Jersey

Markets

All figures are estimates based on publicly available market data and are for general research purposes only. Cap rates, rent estimates, and STR performance are market averages and do not guarantee individual property performance. Consult a licensed real estate professional, CPA, or attorney before making investment decisions. Dr Home Investor does not guarantee the accuracy of third-party market data.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.

Helping physicians build wealth through strategic real estate investing. Vetted, investor-focused Realtors in every market — free to get matched.

© 2024 Physician Property Investor. All rights reserved.

Not investment, legal, or financial advice. Market data sourced from Zillow, AirDNA, and Census Reporter.
Always verify with local data before investing.