Lake George
Lake George is an Adirondack summer resort market well suited to physician investors seeking seasonal short-term rental income. Properties average about $285 per night at 65% occupancy — roughly $185 RevPAR and around $5,558 in monthly revenue — against a purchase price near $385,000. Demand is concentrated in a strong peak season, so doctors should model seasonality carefully in their revenue assumptions. New York STR rules are strict and local regulations are moderate here, so buyers should verify local short-term-rental rules before closing. It's a proven resort STR market with pronounced peak-season cash flow.

Market Analysis
Why physicians are looking at Lake George
Lake George is the Adirondacks' marquee summer resort, and its economics are refreshingly legible: a powerful peak season drives $285/night rates and fills the calendar to 65% annualized occupancy. Concentrated seasonality is not a flaw here — it is the model. For physician investors who underwrite it honestly, a proven resort brand with decades of repeat-visitor tradition offers something the emerging STR towns cannot: demand you do not have to hope into existence.
The numbers, interpreted
The panel: $285/night ADR, 65% occupancy, $185 RevPAR, roughly $5,558/mo gross revenue against a $385,000 basis. Underwrite as a hospitality business and respect the shape of the curve — summer carries the year, so the annual number only holds if you win the peak. Model net after management, cleaning, and furnishing reserves, and stress-test a weak-summer scenario. Within New York's STR set, Saratoga Springs posts the same $285/night on a $485,000 basis with an event-driven August spike, while the Catskills trade at $215/night on the same $385,000 basis. Lake George is the strongest revenue-per-dollar position of the three.
Costs and rules to underwrite
New York's 1.65% property tax rate is a real line at this basis: roughly $6,400/yr on a $385,000 property. Regulation requires double diligence — the state's STR posture is strict and local rules are moderate — so verify local short-term-rental permitting, zoning, and caps before closing. Winterization and off-season carrying costs belong in the model too; the lake does not book many February weekends.
Building your local team in Lake George
Peak season is an on-call month that never ends — and the answer is the same one you use at the hospital: hand the 2 a.m. pages to a professional team, because in July a same-day fix is the difference between a five-star review and a refund. That team will make or break the investment. You want STR management with proven Lake George summer logistics, an investor-focused realtor who knows lakefront premium from lake-adjacent markup, and furnishing capital treated as revenue equipment. When guests compare a dozen listings side by side, themed properties and standout amenities tip the decision — memorable out-earns generic every summer. Dr Home Investor introduces you to vetted local team members, including a Realtor match with boots on the ground, instead of a blind Google search through a resort town's vendor noise.
Bottom line
Lake George is New York's strongest ranked STR value: $385,000 in, roughly $5,558/mo gross, and a proven Adirondack resort brand carrying the demand. It suits physicians who accept seasonal concentration, verify the local rules, and staff the peak properly. Win the summer and the year follows. Explore other New York markets to weigh it against the event-driven and metro-escape alternatives. Weighing vacation-rental income against your timeline to financial independence? See physician FIRE through real estate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lake George a good short-term rental market for physicians?
Yes, for investors who underwrite seasonality honestly. Properties near $385,000 average $285/night at 65% occupancy — roughly $5,558/mo gross — on proven Adirondack summer resort demand.
How much does a short-term rental cost in Lake George?
Roughly $385,000, supporting a $185 RevPAR and about $5,558 in gross monthly revenue — the strongest revenue-per-dollar in New York's ranked STR set.
How seasonal is Lake George STR income?
Heavily peak-weighted: summer carries the year, and the 65% annualized occupancy depends on winning it. Model weak-summer scenarios and off-season carrying costs before buying.
Are short-term rentals legal in Lake George?
Verify first: New York's statewide STR posture is strict and local regulations are moderate, so confirm permits, zoning, and caps with the town before closing.
What operating costs matter most at Lake George?
Peak-season management and turnover, furnishing to a $285/night standard, winterization — and property taxes near $6,400/yr at New York's 1.65% rate on a $385,000 basis.
Investment Snapshot
Median Home Value
$385,000.00
Single family
Monthly rent
$1,450.00
Market Average
Gross rent mult.
22.1x
Lower = Better
Est. cap rate
~3.1%
Gross estimate
Property tax rate
1.65%
State average
Rental Strategy Performance
Monthly rent
$1,450.00
Est Market Average
Gross rent mult.
22.1x
Lower = Better
Est. cap rate
~3.1%
Before financing
All 12
New York
Markets
Binghamton
LTR
•
Rank
1
•
GRM
10.9
Rochester NY
LTR
•
Rank
2
•
GRM
12.3
Syracuse
LTR
•
Rank
3
•
GRM
12.3
Buffalo
LTR
•
Rank
4
•
GRM
14.3
All figures are estimates based on publicly available market data and are for general research purposes only. Cap rates, rent estimates, and STR performance are market averages and do not guarantee individual property performance. Consult a licensed real estate professional, CPA, or attorney before making investment decisions. Dr Home Investor does not guarantee the accuracy of third-party market data.